This Mount Rushmore is certainly up for debate but here is who TGR put on the list.
Mathieu Schneider was the 44th overall drafted pick in 1987. His career included 223 goals and 521 assists. He won a Stanley Cup in 1993 with the Canadiens, was selected to 2 All-Star games, and represented Team USA in the World Cup. Jeff Halpern played for Team USA in the World Championships and had a 15 year NHL career highlighted by 221 career assists. Mike Cammarelli was the 49th overall selection in 2001 and played professionals for 17 years. His accolades include 294 goals and 348 assists. He won a Gold Medal with Canada in the World Championships and played for them as a junior. The final head on the mountain is Jack Hughes. Hughes was the 2019 #1 overall pick. He may not have the stats yet but the #1 pick status places in on the list immediately.
Honorable Mentions: Quinn Hughes, Jason Zucker, Zach Hyman, Eric Nystrom, and Ronnie Stern.