Sid Luckman sits atop the Jewish NFL Mount Rushmore but who joins him? Hall of Famers Ron Mix and Andre Tippett are obvious choices. These are the only three Jewish HoFers. And number 4? Julian Edelman. At this point Edelman is a borderline HoFer but he has captured Jewish football fans attention like no one has done since Luckman.
Others considered include Jay Fiedler, Mitchell Schwartz, Ed Newman, Randy Grossman, and David Binn. None of them were able to edge out Edelman but all had (or are having) solid careers.